Backups are not recovery until restoration is tested

A backup console can report success even when an organization cannot restore a usable business service. Recovery also depends on credentials, encryption keys, software, configuration, infrastructure, documentation, clean systems, and people who know the sequence.

What the official source says

Source fact: CISA’s #StopRansomware Guide recommends maintaining offline, encrypted backups of critical data and regularly testing their availability and integrity in a disaster-recovery scenario. CISA warns that ransomware may attempt to find and delete or encrypt accessible backups. The guide also discusses protected system images, critical-asset prioritization, secured logs, and rebuilding on a clean network.

Define what “restored” means

DSE recommendation: test a complete, representative service rather than restoring a random file and calling the exercise finished. Before the test, document the business owner, technical owner, approved test environment, recovery point being tested, expected dependencies, validation method, and stop conditions.

Identify the authoritative backup set and confirm that access is restricted.

Confirm required credentials, recovery keys, licenses, installers, configuration, certificates, and documentation.

Use an isolated or otherwise approved destination that will not overwrite production data.

Scan or validate recovered material according to the organization’s incident and recovery plan.

Have the business owner verify that the restored information or application is complete and usable.

Record elapsed time, errors, manual work, missing dependencies, and the exact evidence retained.

Review the failure modes

A restoration test should look beyond backup-job status. Check whether one compromised identity could reach production systems and backup administration, whether deletion protections can be changed too easily, whether alerts reach an attended destination, and whether the documented recovery order matches current business dependencies. Cloud data also needs an explicit recovery decision; provider availability, retention, recycle bins, version history, and a separate backup are different capabilities.

DSE recommendation: treat every failed or partially successful test as useful evidence. Open remediation items with owners and due dates, then repeat the affected portion. Preserve safe test records without including passwords, recovery keys, customer data, or sensitive topology in a broadly accessible report.

Claims to avoid

Do not advertise a recovery-time objective, recovery-point objective, immutability guarantee, or successful disaster recovery unless the organization has defined the metric and produced current test evidence. One restored file does not validate an application, and one application test does not validate the entire environment.

Practical next step: choose one important but safely testable service. Restore it to an approved location, have the owner validate it, document every dependency, and schedule the next test based on risk and change rate.